5 minute read time
Post originally published March 2016, updated April 2020.
Choosing the right email service provider (ESP) is like finding the perfect shoe. You can limp along if that shoe is too big or too small, but you’ll only get optimal comfort and performance from a great fit.
So how do you get there?
Read on as we offer five actionable tips for choosing the right email service provider (ESP) for your business.
An ESP is an email service provider. An ESP is the place that houses your inbox, sent spam, and draft emails. If you want to communicate with modern society effectively, you need an ESP.
When email was first invented, there was only MAILBOX and SNDMSG, and now there are millions to choose from.
Some of today’s top ESP providers include
Data security is a huge issue in today’s society.
According to a study done by Hotspot, “150 billion emails are sent every day, and of those 150 billion sent each one has about 15 attachments every day. 53% claim that they lose files that have sensitive information on it.”
This can mean that your information is available for anyone to get their hands on.
Although there are preventative measures to take to ensure that this doesn’t happen, it is something to think about when you’re choosing an ESP.
What makes ESP email marketing so effective?
The cost is relatively low, and the upside can be tremendous. It’s easy to start and you can begin as big or small as you like.
But before you start testing solutions and providers, it’s important to figure out how email marketing fits into your overall marketing strategy.
Email is 40 times more effective at acquiring new customers than Facebook or Twitter.
With all that potential, it’s vital to make sure you have clear goals, processes, and tools in place.
Questions to consider as you build an email marketing strategy:
Remember: The purpose of email marketing is to build relationships and grow your business, so think about where your business will be in a year or two and make sure your provider can scale with you.
Below are four must-have features in any email service provider (ESP).
You’ll want to make sure your email provider offers the features you need and that it’s easy to use. Once you prioritize the features you need and want, you can better evaluate potential providers.
The key part of email marketing is the emails. So you need an email service provider that helps you create simple, elegant emails quickly and easily. Look for a provider with a range of designs, flexible layouts, and mobile-friendly templates that look great on any device. Free image hosting is an added bonus.
Those beautiful emails won’t do you much good if you don’t know how they perform. Make sure your email service provides a consolidated dashboard with all the statistics you need; open rates, clicks, bounces, unsubscribes, and social sharing—both large scale and drill down.
It’s important to send the most relevant messages to the right people at the right time, and automation helps you do that. Make sure your email service provider offers solid workflows to help you schedule and send automated messages.
Your emails must work across the various devices people use to consume email. Today, 53% of email campaigns are opened on mobile devices, while 28% are opened on desktop clients, and 23% are opened in Webmail. Unless your email campaigns are specifically optimized to work across all of those devices and clients, you’re missing out on conversions and revenue.
Email doesn’t need a big budget to be effective but, in marketing, effective often isn’t enough. If you want awesome campaigns and analytics, you need to make sure you’ve got the appropriate budget in place.
There are very basic free email marketing tools available and there are email marketing tools that cost tens of thousands of dollars with heaps of advanced functionality.
While enterprise-level providers may seem attractive in theory, if you don’t actually use all those extra features (which can take a lot of time to learn how to use) you’re just throwing good money away.
You have your choice of low, medium, and enterprise-level providers. Choosing the right one for your needs can keep your costs low and the return on your efforts high, while still delivering the functionality you need.
Keep in mind that investing in email can result in a much better payoff than investing the same amount in search or social.
In fact, email marketing yields an average 3800% return on investment for businesses in the United States.
Budget tip: Look for an ESP that offers a variety of payment plans. Most services offer monthly subscription plans for those who mail regularly and have sizable lists; however, some include the ability to “pay-as-you-go” for less frequent senders.
Why? Because, by investing in your email programs, you’re building customer relationships. Investing more in email marketing doesn’t just mean sending more email.
To have a chance of engaging customers and prospects, your messages have to land in their inboxes.
Not every email service provider can ensure your emails get delivered at the same rate. Ask potential email service providers about their delivery rate and how they work with their customers to keep that rate high.
You want to look for an average delivery rate of 98% or higher.
Look for providers that have solid relationships with internet giants like Microsoft, Google, and Yahoo.
Keep in mind that delivery rates are a combination of how the email service provider ensures delivery to inboxes on the backend and how you use the service, so be sure to ask for any resources they offer on best practices for content and list management.
Your email service provider should function as an extension of your marketing team—seamlessly and without much hassle.
But there will be an occasions when you’ll need some help. When that happens, it’s critical to have access to a smart and resourceful customer support team to help you address any issue.
See how long it takes to get through to a rep via email or on the phone.
Browse the online knowledge base.
Ask for help importing your list or creating segments.
Ask what other resources they offer to help customers succeed.
While a lot of the free ESP tools might seem appealing, many aren’t set up to support you when you really need it. If you’re a professional marketer—with goals and KPIs to achieve—you need to know that, if something goes wrong, you can get help quickly.
You’re much better off using a professional email tool that offers around-the-clock customer support.
Choosing the perfect email service provider is critical to your company’s success, but it doesn’t have to be hard. Use the tips in this guide and this handy checklist to help make your choice.
From personalized subject lines to dynamic content to send time optimization, Campaign Monitor helps you build campaigns catered to every last subscriber.Learn More
We started out helping agencies with email, so let us help you.
With our powerful yet easy-to-use tools, it's never been easier to make an impact with email marketing.Try it for free